How to Disagree with Your Spouse and Win!

How to Disagree with Your Spouse and Win!1 min read

Conflict can have damaging effects on a marriage. But the damage is not caused by husbands and wives disagreeing with each other. The damage is caused by how husbands and wives handle their disagreements.

At the University of California, Berkeley, researchers Aimee Gordon and Serena Chen collected data in seven different studies of romantically attached couples. Their research compared couples who frequently engage in conflict with those who rarely argue. They concluded that the feeling that one’s point of view is understood by their partner protects couples against the negative effects of their conflicts. These couples are no less satisfied than couples who rarely wrestle with disagreements.

Many disagreements are small and can be easily resolved. For example, my wife and I can sometimes disagree on whether we need to mow the lawn today or tomorrow. I’ll say it’s still too wet. She’ll say it’s too long. We work it out without tensions rising more than a notch or two. These small disagreements don’t stir up strong emotions. One way or another it will get done within the next few days.

Dealing with Big Disagreements in a Marriage

Bigger disagreements tend to stir up a lot of negative emotion, such as disagreements about how to spend money, where to live, or how to raise children. When searching for our current home, my wife and I disagreed on where it should be located. We both agreed we wanted to move out of the suburbs into a rural setting. But she wanted our home to be nearer to the suburbs than I did. As we looked at real estate listings, we frequently argued about whether a home was too close in or too far out.

Sometimes we’d find ourselves gridlocked and have to table the discussion and come back to it after we’d calmed down. There were times before this when tensions rose high and big arguments ended with one or both of us being angry. We didn’t know how to lower the tension.

Then we learned how to lower the emotional tension and acknowledge each other’s strongly held positions. While our disagreements temporarily raised the tension between us, we didn’t let it lower our relationship satisfaction. This is a trait common among many satisfied couples who run up against strong disagreements. This is how it’s done:

1) Discover each other’s dreams.

Sit together. Consider holding hands or each other.  Positive touch is physically soothing and can lower the tension between you.

Take turns telling each other what your world would look like if the disagreement were resolved. While each spouse takes their turn talking, the other listens. Express your dream in positive terms, telling your spouse what you want, rather than what you don’t want.

The listener’s goal is to understand the other’s dream. Be curious, and ask for more detail or explanations that may help you see the issue through your spouse’s eyes.

Once a spouse finishes sharing their dream, the listener’s task is to explain in his or her own words what they understood the dream to be. When doing this, avoid criticizing your spouse’s dream. Don’t get defensive when he or she expresses wishes you haven’t granted. And never say to each other, “You need to calm down.”

If the tension gets too uncomfortable, acknowledge your own need to calm down. Agree on a time-out and make plans to pick up the discussion later on when you both have low levels of tension. Then give each other some space and do something physically soothing to let off some steam.

2) Support each other’s dreams.

After each spouse has taken their turn telling the other their dream, give your support to each other, if you can. Consider these different levels of support:

Showing continued interest. After this initial discussion is over, continue to be curious about your spouse’s dream. Ask questions about it, and listen without judging, criticizing or getting defensive.

For example, when my wife and I were looking at properties, I’d ask my wife if she thought it was too far out of her comfort zone. She’d tell me if it was. When I was at my best, I’d just listen and acknowledge her concerns. Showing interest doesn’t mean you agree, but that you care.

Sponsor his or her dream. In many situations, a spouse can support their husband or wife’s dream without taking part in it. This may be through verbal encouragement, financial support, or giving time and effort to make at least part of that dream come true

Several years ago, I dreamed of taking my wife and daughter to Africa for a short-term mission experience. My wife refused to go. But one day she surprised me by telling me she wanted me and my daughter to go. She even researched and found an organization we could travel with to Kenya on a two-week service project.

Make the dream come true. Sometimes after a husband and wife understand each other's dreams, love compels one or both to compromise. This involves trading part or all of your dream for your spouse’s happiness. That’s what we did to finally settle on a location for our home. The home we chose isn’t as remote as I wanted, and isn’t as close to as my wife wanted. But, for both of us, it has become a happy place, because understood and respected each other’s dreams.

How to Disagree with Your Spouse and Win! #marriage

Click to Tweet

A version of this post also appeared on LifeZette.com.

Jon Beaty

I'm a counselor, writer and believer in the power of God to help you thrive in your marriage and family. I live with my family, a small herd of Boer goats, and thousands of honeybees near Portland, Oregon.

>